Thursday, October 1, 2015

Can Students Make the Rules?

In one of my classes, we recently discussed the pros and cons of rules in the class. The professor spoke of one teacher that she knew. The teacher in the story decided to let the students arbitrarily make the rules for the class themselves. In the story, some of the rules the students implemented made other students in the class uncomfortable. Now, my first impression was what was that teacher thinking?! How could she give complete control of her classroom up?!

Upon further reflection, I realized: that actually could work… when used properly. I reflected on my experience as an RA. In one of our first staff meetings, we made rules for our individual staff. Yes, our supervisor gave us some guidelines and expectations of what she wanted us to do. Those included actually doing our job and things along those lines. But, we made our own rules to govern ourselves with. For example, you can’t text in the GroupMe past midnight, and you cannot wait until the last minute to complete your part for our group collaborations.

I want to teach middle school. Students in these grades are beginning to want to be a part of the planning process. I know that when I was in middle school, I would have loved to help make some of the rules for the class. There are even classes that I am currently in that I wish had been able to do this! In of my lectures, everyone obnoxiously packs up before class is even over, when the professor is still speaking.

In my future class, I would probably have to give some basic guidelines, including no bullying and no texting in class (or whatever is popular in the future). But it is also important to guide our students in how they make the rules. This can happen with questions such as How do we decide who is talking next? The only way for this idea to be effective is if I tell them that I will have final say over all rules. I can veto them if I choose, explain why, and if it is possible they may rewrite it. I think the original goal of the first teacher was to get her students involved, which is an idea that I completely respect and am totally behind. It just has to be done in the right way that allows for equal participation among all students. The primary goal has to be to facilitate a positive learning environment, everything else will fall into place.